New York's building code requires a registered design professional to prepare a site-specific excavation support plan before any dig deeper than a shallow footing — not a boilerplate sheet, an engineered plan stamped for that lot. A new ENR report says an engineer flagged exactly that requirement on the Brooklyn site next to the Flatbush Avenue building that collapsed this week, warning before work was halted that the planned excavation needed its own design review and didn't have one.

ENR's reporting, credited here as first reported by ENR, centers on Title 28, Chapter 33 of the NYC Construction Codes — the sitework and foundation provisions that require a Technical Report (TR1) and a professionally engineered support-of-excavation plan whenever a dig approaches or undermines an adjacent structure's foundation. The rule exists because soil removed next to an old foundation can take the lateral support out from under it, and a wall that stood for a century can fail in hours once that support is gone.

DOB's own process requires the filed plan to be reviewed and signed off before excavation work proceeds past the point the plan covers — and requires a licensed professional to monitor the dig against that plan as it happens, not just approve paper up front. Under Local Law 10/2020's enforcement amendments, a site found excavating without an approved support plan next to an occupied structure can draw a full stop-work order, not just a violation, because the risk is to the building next door, not just the job site itself.

For a GC or excavation sub pricing a job with an adjacent structure, this is the line item that gets skipped when a schedule is tight: engineering a support-of-excavation plan takes weeks a fast-moving demolition schedule doesn't always budget for. ENR's report does not establish that the Flatbush collapse was caused by the excavation next door — DOB and the Brooklyn DA's office have both said that determination is still open — but the code requirement it describes is not in dispute and applies on every site in the five boroughs where a dig sits next to an existing building.

A contractor who skips the engineered plan and self-certifies a dig as routine earns the schedule savings today and the stop-work order, the DOB violation, and the civil liability exposure later — exposure that does not go away if the adjacent building doesn't collapse, because DOB can cite the gap in enforcement sweeps independent of any incident.