Across the one thousand bid tabulations in The RFI Wire's board, the average low bid comes in 5.2% under the engineer's own estimate. That is the agency's paperwork saying one number and the job clearing at something a little lower.
Now here is the part that does not line up at first glance: the average spread between the low bid and the rest of the field sits at 89.2%. That is not a tight field bunched around a number. That is a low bidder landing nowhere near the pack, and a second or third bidder coming in dramatically higher.
“Estimators are not missing by much on where the market clears. The field around that number is wide open.”
Put those two together and you get the real picture of New York public bidding right now: estimators are not missing by much on where the market actually clears, but the field around that number is wide open. One contractor finds the number. The rest do not come close.
That combination only shows up when a job draws a deep bench of bidders with very different cost structures — a crew that already owns the right equipment, already has a super free, already knows the site, pricing it tight, against firms pricing it from a colder start. The average bidder count across the sample is 8.3, enough bidders for that gap to open up without it being one lucky outlier skewing the whole number.
A thin spread would tell a contractor the market has converged on a price and there's no room to win on anything but relationships or schedule. An 89.2% average spread says the opposite: there is real room between a sharp number and a safe number, and the agencies' own estimates are, on average, still a reasonable target to price toward.
The caveat that matters here: this average sits across wildly different job types and sizes, from a $4,000 library repair to a nine-figure transit contract, and a handful of huge spreads on small jobs can move an average percentage more than they would move a dollar figure. Read it as a market signal, not a bid-by-bid guarantee.
What this means for you: If you're pricing close to the agency's posted estimate, you're in the right neighborhood on average — the real competition is against a field that spreads out wide, so a tight, well-researched number has real room to win. How we count: Figures cover 1,000 tabulated bid results on The RFI Wire's board: average bidder count, the average percentage spread between the low and other bids, and the average percentage the low bid sits above or below the agency's engineer's estimate, where that estimate was published.